Lyndaf, I relate. I have spent a lot of money on the wrong color products befor realizing you can return at high end stores

. I am very loyal to my Makeup For Ever foundation, so I didn't expect it to like Stila's.
But, yeah, the color selection-not so great. Check out Ulta, or Macy's has more similar Stila products in a variety of colors. I haven't tried any of them but I am really liking Stila lately. Their Kitten eyeshadow is my favorite-very basic champagne.