I agree, it would be nice to know the pros and cons of different yarns.
frostygooseAK, I love hand spun yarn and often buy it on Etsy. I think there's something special about buying it directly from the person who spun it.
In fact,yesterday I received some handspun alpaca yarn that was spun especially for me by Julie Petty, who has an
Etsy store. I met her on Facebook through our mutual interest in knitting and alpacas and when I asked her if she could spin 2 skeins of one yarn for me, she was glad to do it. Can't wait to use it!
Most of the time the handspun on Etsy is only made in 80 yards or less and you need more to do much of a project.