Most of my answers will probably be WWE only, simply because I've seen a lot less TNA (and almost nothing from ROH) lately.
Best Face -
John Cena: While he might not be compared to Bret Hart anytime soon, he managed to carry the belt for the better part of the year, had bigger matches than any other face in the WWE, and got the biggest reactions of anyone besides DX.
Best Heel -
Edge: Unlike Patty, I love him, and he is a great heel, easily the best in the WWE without having to rely on "I'm a monster, grr" that the other heels tend to.
Best Alliance/Faction/Stable - Besides, DX...well, there was King Booker's stable (Royal Court, whatever)...there was the Spirit Squad...so, not so much on the good. Hmph. Heck, I might as well say the DX/Hardys/Punk team from Survivor Series, just because they were the best, just not the longest-lived
Best Storyline - Again, with the not-so-much. I can't think of one that stands out as 'best'. Maybe I'm not the best person to answer this thing, eh?
Wrestler of the Year - From the tiny bit I saw of him in TNA, I do have to say
Samoa Joe. Above and beyond any other wrestler, simply because he had the crowd wrapped around his little finger without even saying anything (and I know we are talking about the Orlando crowd, who annoy me muchly, but still...) And he's so much better than you think he would be just by looking at him (sorry Joe). WWE wise?
Edge.Diva or Knockout of the Year -
Trish Stratus, because after she won the title, Mickie disappeared - otherwise, it would be Mickie.
Match of the Year - Same as Patty. I've got nothing.
PPV of the Year - I can't say, because I watched two, I think. Wrestlemania and a TNA one that I can't even remember. Sting won, Angle was enforcer, my memory is cheese.
Feelgood Moment of the Year -
Trish winning the belt on the way out: I agree completely with Patty. Easily the best.
Promotion (or Brand) of the Year - Pre-Russo I would have said TNA. But not them, and not the WWE.
Most Improved Wrestler -
Carlito. I just can't like Nitro (sorry!). But Carlito kept pulling out new moves all the time, so kudos to him.
The Fall from Grace Award -
The X-Division on TNA. Through absolutely no fault of their own. Remember the Joe-Daniels-Styles match? When was the last time the X-Division was featured like that - the other talents might not be at that level, but give them something! Although I do agree about Batista - if he focussed on improving his wrestling and character as much as he did on getting jobs for the girls he is dating, maybe people might start caring again.
Long Overdue to be Fired - Russo. Making Jonny Ace look like less of a wanker is an achievement.
Newcomer of the Year -
Punk. To be as over as he was in Survivor Series, 'twas awesome.
