Those are a little traditional for my taste. I do, however want something very feminine. The only one I like is Lucy and it doesn't flow very well with Tuesday. Any more suggestions? I wanted the first name to be Evelyn (Evy as a NN), but I feel it doesn't go with Tuesday either.
I like the suggestions of Olivia and Corrine (any spelling, so long as it makes sense phonetically).
I have to disagree on Melody, though. Two nouns in a row like that -- especially when they form a phrase -- could elicit teasing. I'd say the same about names like...say, Scarlet Crystal, or Sky Raven, or Daisy Blossom. They just seem over the top to me.
Here are some other ideas for middles to go with Tuesday:
Alexa
Alyssa
Ariana
Chloe
Colette
Delia
Eliza
Fiona
Isabella
Jenna
Jillian
Marcella
Melissa
Odelia
Rosalie
Sabina
Zoe