ok, i cant really choose between these four but they are all i awesome. the best i can do is rate them on a scale, but its just that...some are better played once through and others are good to play like, four times. ok here they are:
1) Final Fantasy 8 (probably the best rpg EVER made, with the best characters and story-line, and practically everything about it, in fact...i think ill go play it tonight)
2) Chrono Cross (really good to play over a bunch of times cuz of the new game+ feature)
3) Final Fantasy 10 (really good story, but really challenging at the same time. i get stuck about every place there is to go in that game ((right now im stuck fighting seymore on mt. gagazet)) so...well, yea)
4) Legend of the Dragoon (also a really good, but really challenging game ((im stuck fighting Lenus in the twin caslte in fletz)) yup...good story line.)