Dani,
www.singleservecoffee.com is the best for reviews on anything single serve. Whether for pod makers, Keurig or Tassimo and other more expensive coffee shop machines they have info on everything.
I have a Krups two cup maker that my husband got me for Christmas and then I got a Tassimo from a survey company and I really love that as well. There were so many benefits to both that I kept both of them (better latte and cappacino in the Tassimo).
While the press and other makers are probably better tasting I will admit if you do buy a good coffee to run through your machine you will be happier than with most of the Senseo brand coffees. The brands they sell in the store are all kind of weak. Does Senseo have a special attachment to hold your own ground coffee?
I will tell you that the best I've run through my Krups is Senseo Sumatra (I had to get it on auto delivery from Amazaon with their Hazelnut). It is rich and holds the sugar and cream well if you like that. They sell a variety pack with four different Senseo brands to try if you want to go that route.
Gevalia sells tea pods that are excellent, they should have coffee pods, but I can't remember. I also get their disks for the Tassimo. I liked a company called Cool Beans (or cool beanz, I can't remember it has been so long) but Amazon didn't have them the last I looked.
All I can say is congrats. I love have single serve as I don't waste a pot of coffee and it is fresh every time, it is a little trade off to the perfect cup from other methods but through trial and error you will find something you like.
Have FUN!