I believe that parents are making a mistake to punish poor grades. If the poor grades are the result of distractions, including too much focus on socializing, sports, television watching, etc. then it is obvious you need to explain that and make corrections in the child's study schedule. And yes, schedule study periods at home!
If the poor grades are the result of just "not getting" the subject matter, help her. If you can't because you don't have time, hook her up with a mentor, peer pal, tutor or after school time with the teacher. If you don't get the subject matter yourself, take the time to learn along with her. How can you expect your child to learn if you don't want to?
If the poor grades are the result of honest effort and, for some reason, inability to understand the material (developmental challenges or low IQ), then absolutely be okay with it. And express that you are proud of her efforts and that is what really matters: doing her best. Then, help her find other areas where she can excel and express her gifts and talents.
Parents have to get off the whole punishment and reward system. Learning and feeling good about your intellectual progress (being smarter) is the reward. Realizing you are behind your peers is punishment enough. Even if kids say they don't care, they honestly do care inside.
If a kid is self-motivated, she will learn and succeed on her own without anyone pushing her or dangling bribes that will need to get bigger and better to keep her interested. Teachers and parents forget that this information is fascinating if approached properly.
Last edited by Lori Chidori - Marriage; 03/15/11 04:42 PM.