Warning: This contain spoilers.

Bad movie.
I hate musicals but if the music in this would of been better I would of liked this one. The choreographies are great but that is it as far as the musical part of this movie goes. Not all the songs sucks but the ones that does not are ruined by the voice of the singers. I loved that the present time is filmed in black and white and that the past is filmed in color. I started to cry when he put the music box on her tomb and cried more when I saw the black rose.
The script is very bad. The acting and music are bad. The special effects are average. The directing, cinematography, editing, makeup, sets and story are good. The costumes are excellent.