After giving this way more thought than I should, I decided on a sunscreen moisturizer. Everything else is optional.
Can we please rename this thread to: If you had to give up ONE piece of makeup, what would it be? It's just causing way too much anxiety!(In me for sure, I don't know about everyone else, but this is a pretty hefty thread...)
So here's the one thing I have let go of: mascara. Before allergies, mascara was a fetish. Now, if I so much as watch a streaming video, my eyes start to water, so mascara has been retired.
Contrariwise, when I was younger and presumably better looking, it was full war paint most of the time. Now, not so much, except for Occasions of State and even then, I might forego foundation. No one has complained (within earshot).
Ya'll are beautiful!